Whale Photography Guide

Dave

Administrator
Staff member
This guide is primarily focused on photographing whales from shore in the Pacifica area. Of course many of these tips are applicable to other areas and circumstances, and I will also have a few mentions about photographing from a boat.

Last Updated - October 26, 2024

Contents​



Equipment​

People almost always start their questions with equipment. While it's undeniably an essential piece of the equation, often too much is made of the equipment and not enough around strategy, composition, etc.

One of my biggest pieces of advice on equipment is also one of the most difficult for some people: learn to love the equipment you have and how to take good photographs within the confines of your equipment. You can take great photos with almost any camera. Will you be able to get the same shots as someone with a $5K camera and $15k lens? Will you be able to count the individual baleen hairs in the whale's mouth? No. But that doesn't mean you can't get a great photo. You just need to learn what photographs you can get with your equipment and focus on getting the best shot you can. It may sound obvious, but it's a lot more difficult to do than it sounds.

My second biggest piece of advice is "try before you buy", especially with the more expensive cameras and lenses. There are good options for renting gear around. You can try doing a google search. Personally I have used lensrentals.com and borrowlenses.com. Borrow Lenses used to have a local store in San Carlos. However it appears that Lensrentals has purchased Borrow Lenses and no longer has local pickup at the Borrow Lenses storefront. This is unfortunate, however I've had great experiences with Lensrentals and they make the shipment process easy. It ships directly to you via FedEx, often overnight. They provide everything you need to ship back, all you have to do is drop it at the nearest FedEx dropoff.


Camera Bodies​

For now I'm going to focus on cameras that allow you to change lenses because that's what I know best. I am also going to start by assuming the reader has general photography knowledge. I may later fill in some additional general photography information and information on other types of cameras.

DSLR vs MILC​

If you haven't heard the term MILC, that's Mirrorless Interchangeable Lens Camera - it's like a DSLR but instead of an optical viewfinder you have a digital viewfinder, so you're generally seeing almost exactly what the captured image is going to look like, including exposure settings. If you're looking to buy a new camera, I'd personally recommend looking at MILCs - that is where the whole camera industry is headed and there are some nice advantages, including being easier and much better at doing video. But if you have a DSLR, don't worry, you can still get fantastic photos with your gear.

Brand​

I won't really delve into which manufacturer has the "best" camera - all of the top manufacturers make excellent cameras and it's hard to really go wrong with any of them. If you're buying new, make sure to consider what lenses are available. Many photographers choose their camera more based on lenses than they do on the camera body.

Full-frame vs Crop Body​

This is a long discussion with pros and cons for each and I'm not going to try and rehash this right now. I'd recommend doing a google search if you want to know more. For the purposes of this guide and a quick understanding - full-frame refers to a camera which has a sensor close to the size of what 35mm film cameras use, so in general it behaves like a 35mm film camera. Crop bodies have smaller sensors.

The major effect you will notice from a crop body is that the image appears "zoomed in" more when using the same focal length lens. Often the crop factor is roughly 1.5, referred to as APS-C, though some manufacturers are 1.6. Another common crop factor is 2.0, referred to as Micro Four Thirds. If you have a 1.5 crop and you put a 100mm focal length lens on it, the view will be roughly equivalent to what you would see with a 150mm (100*1.5) lens on a full-frame body. So when looking at and discussing lenses you'll need to be aware of whether the length given is the actual focal length or the equivalent focal length. For the sake of my guide, I'm going to refer to the actual focal length and using it on a full-frame camera. If you're using a crop body, you'll need to adjust accordingly.

One more note on crop bodies, relating to depth of field. Without going into too much detail, the depth of field for a crop body will also be different. For a 1.5 crop there is a roughly 1 f-stop difference in depth of field compared to a full-frame if you maintain the same distance between yourself and the subject. Things get a little more complicated if you talk about changing distances to maintain the same field of view, and other variations. But for the purposes of this guide, since your position to the whale will typically not change, you can just adjust things by 1 f-stop. So for example, if I say I'm using an f-stop of f4 to get the whole whale in focus with a 600mm lens, if you're using a 600mm lens on an APSC camera, you would need to go to f5.6 to get the whole whale in focus.

My Camera​

Personally I shoot with a Nikon Z9 MILC. I stick with Nikon because I'm most familiar with them and I have a lot of Nikon lenses. The Z9 is a fantastic body and continues to get better with every software update. There are other, less expensive Nikon bodies which would work just as well. As a bonus, even though it's a mirrorless, you can use an adapter and still use your old DSLR-style F-mount lenses. I was skeptical of using a lens with an adapter, but my F-mount lenses work at least as well, and in some cases better, on my Z9 than they did on my D850.


Lenses​

Since this guide is primarily focused on shooting from shore, the short answer is "the longer the better". However there are some caveats with that advice. The first is that in general, the longer the lens the more expensive it will be. So you need to decide how important getting close-up photos are to you. Or you can learn to be happy with taking wider shots. Longer lenses with wider apertures are even more expensive. It's generally helpful to have a wider aperture so that you can use faster shutter speeds. However there are techniques and styles that can be employed to help get reasonable shots even with "slow glass" (lenses with smaller apertures). The bigger issue you may run into with slow glass comes when you're shooting with a DSLR instead of a MILC. Often the smaller apertures will impact the ability of the camera to auto focus, as discussed later.

Zoom vs Prime​

Zoom lenses allow you to use a range of different focal lengths. Prime lenses are fixed to a single focal length. There are pros and cons to each. In general, zoom lenses are more flexible and are often less expensive than their prime counterparts. On the flip-side, zoom lenses typically are slower (smaller aperture) and slightly lower quality. That being said, some of the modern zoom lenses stack up pretty well against prime lenses and if you're not shooting for National Geographic you're probably not going to notice much, if any, difference. The primary difference you'll notice is the difference in aperture, as you'll tend to use a slower shutter speed, higher ISO or both. But if your main target is social media, you're not trying to print huge prints and/or sell your photos, a good zoom lens is probably what you want to be looking at. If you're a Nikon Z shooter, they recently released a 180-600mm lens that is really good especially for the price. But all the major manufacturers have a zoom lens that is somewhere in the range of 150-600mm which is a great, versatile lens when you need to be able to shoot fairly long distances.

Super Telephotos​

Super telephoto lenses typically refer to lenses 400mm and longer. Often people think "oh, it would be so much easier if I had a super telephoto lens! I could easily get shots similar to those beautiful shots I see getting posted!" But buyer beware! Super telephotos are different animals altogether. The first problem people tend to run into is simply getting the lens pointed at the subject. The field of view with super teles is very narrow so as soon as you put your face to the eyepiece you get a very limited view. Just pointing it in the right direction, and knowing which way to move the lens to get it on the subject is difficult. And with the super teles, the depth of field is pretty narrow, so you might be pointed at the subject but just out of focus and it can be hard to tell what's going on. There's also the weight - the lenses are heavier and can be difficult to keep pointed at a subject if you're hand-holding. Using a tripod helps with this, but can be cumbersome especially if you're on the pier and/or trying to work your way in with a crowd. A monopod is a reasonable compromise - it gives you more stability than hand-holding and bears most of the weight of the camera and lens, but is more flexible and manueverable than a tripod. When I'm shooting with big glass, I often shoot with a monopod.

One of the big issues with long glass that catches quite a few photographers offguard is "atmospheric distortion". When you're shooting with long lenses, you're typically shooting over long distances. That puts a lot of atmosphere between you and your subject. That atmosphere can cause problems. The most common problem is "heat distortion". But note that heat distortion doesn't exist just where or when it's hot - you can get it in the arctic. The real issue is when you have air with different temperatures mixing together. And unfortunately that is all too common when you're shooting around the Pacific ocean. You'll have the sun warming the air and/or warming the land which warms the air and then you get breezes which mix that warm air with cold air from the ocean. Any time you have air with different temperatures between you and your subject, you're going to get at least some level of heat distortion. If all of your photos are blurry and/or if everything in your photo is blurry (there's no real sharp/crisp area) then likely you're dealing with heat distortion. There isn't much you can do about this other than find ways to avoid whatever is causing the heat distortion. This will be discussed in more detail in the shooting strategies section.

Something else to be aware of when using super telephoto lenses - most of them come with a "lens foot" which is designed to be the place where you mount it to a tripod. This provides a better balance point - if you tried to attach your camera to the tripod, it would likely tip over due to being very front-heavy. But more importantly, the mount that connects your lens to your camera is not designed to carry much weight or stress. The weight of a super telephoto lens is generally too much for this mount point. You should not pick up your camera+lens by the camera body. You should pick it up by the lens foot. Similarly, you should not attach a lens strap to your camera body, you should attach it to the lens. Failure to do so will likely lead to a premature death of your camera-to-lens mount. While there are some potential exceptions, a general rule is that if your lens comes with a lens foot, it's likely too heavy for your camera's lens mount and should be handled, carried and supported by the lens foot. Many long lenses also provide strap attachment points on the lens, so you can attach your strap there instead of the lens foot. So before you go out and drop a bunch of money on a super telephoto lens, I'd recommend renting or borrowing one first to see if you're willing and able to manage the longer lenses.

What Length?​

As mentioned earlier, "the longer the better" (with caveats). A really good length for shooting whales from shore is 600mm. And 600mm is a very common go-to length for many wildlife photographers, so it's a pretty versatile lens if shooting wildlife is a big interest of yours. It can be used to photograph small birds up close, big birds from farther away, large mammals from a "safe distance", etc. On the exotic/expensive side, many wildlife photographers use a 600mm prime lens with an aperture of f4. But a good zoom lens that's less expensive and goes out to 600mm is a great choice.

If you don't have, or don't want to get, something in the 600mm range, you can look closer to 400mm and consider adding a teleconverter. Teleconverters do reduce quality somewhat, but the bigger issue is the loss of light. A 1.4X teleconverter causes a 1 f-stop loss of light. A 2X teleconverter causes a 2 f-stop loss of light. This is becoming less of an issue as denoise software gets better-and-better. However you do need to consider the impacts of the smaller aperture on autofocus if you're shooting with a DSLR, as discussed later. Modern teleconverters on modern cameras can provide excellent results - I use them regularly. While you will probably notice a slight reduction in quality with a 2X if you look closely, most people won't notice the difference with a 1.4X.

Slow Glass​

As briefly mentioned earlier, there can be issues with slow lenses and autofocus. This primarily impacts DSLR users. MILCs tend not to suffer as much trouble because they are autofocusing with the actual, full sensor, whereas DSLRs are focusing using a small sensor behind the mirror. I won't go into all of the details, but in general on DSLRs, the smaller the aperture of the lens, the slower and less accurate the autofocus will be. In addition, the smaller the aperture, the fewer autofocus points are available for the camera to use. You may only be able to focus if the subject is right near the center of the frame, as opposed to off to the side somewhat. And on many cameras, you also start to lose "cross" autofocus sensors which do both vertical and horizontal and they get reduced to just being vertical. However note when I refer to "smaller aperture" I'm referring to the maximum aperture of the lens, not the aperture that you have set for your photo. The camera focuses with the aperture wide open, so the only thing that matters is how wide the maximum aperture is, not the aperture you have set. And most DSLRs have a minimum aperture for autofocus to operate. This can be f8 on some of the better camera bodies, and may only be f5.6 on some bodies. So be aware of the autofocus issues when choosing your lens and/or whether to try using a teleconverter. In general, faster glass is better, but is almost always more expensive.

Brands​

You might wonder if you need to get lenses made by the same manufacturer as your camera body. The answer is, generally no. There are excellent third-party lenses out there. Among the big names are Sigma and Tamron. Sigma has a reputation of having higher quality, and Tamron has a reputation of being cheaper. But both companies make great lenses and I own lenses from both of them. Nikon has even started re-branding some Tamron lenses as Nikon lenses.

I tend to lean toward using Nikon lenses, in part because I do think they are at least slightly higher quality, but also because they have a really solid lineup, including some rather unique lenses such as their lenses that have built-in teleconverters. You basically just flip a switch and it engages/disengages the teleconverter so you can quickly and easily switch between two different focal lengths while maintaing "prime lens quality". Also, at least on Nikon with some of their bodies (including the Z9), if you're using native Nikon glass, they will perform "synchronized image stabilization" where the lens stabilization works in coordination with the in-body image stabilization. You can get upwards of 5 and 6 f-stops of stabilization. Just think about being able to hand-hold an 800mm lens at 1/25 sec??? I've done it and it's pretty amazing. And speaking of their 800mm lens, the new Nikon Z 800mm lens is really something to behold. It's literally half the weight of my f-mount Nikon 800mm, less than half the price and a fair bit shorter. Every time I pick it up, I pick it up a bit too fast because I'm expecting something a lot heavier. I can pretty easily hand-hold it, which is amazing for an 800mm. But I digress ...

Again, you should have very few reservations about using third-party lenses. There are sometimes advantages
to using the same manufacturer as your body, but is far from required.


Lens Filters​

About the only lens filter that is applicable for whale shots is a polarizing filter. These filters filter out any light rays that are coming from a different direction than where the filter is lined up. They rotate so that you can adjust the light rays which get filtered. One of the big advantages is they reduce reflections. I've tried using polarizing filters for my whale shots a number of times and I've mostly given up. There are a few issues I've found with using polarizing filters for whale photos:
  1. They cut down the light a fair bit, which is a precious commodity for whale shots with long lenses.
  2. Filters on long lenses are often pretty expensive and difficult to manage. The "exotic" long lenses make it a little easier by having a drop-in filter slot close to the camera body, so the filters are smaller and easier to control, but still take effort.
  3. With the polarizing filter, you can screw up a photo as easily (arguably more easily) as improving it. If you don't have it rotated to the correct position for the direction of light, you can make things worse. Keeping that rotated correctly as the whales move to different positions relative to you and the light is just another complication.
  4. You can do a lot of what the filter does just in software and get nearly the same effect.


Tripod Heads and Gimbals​

If you're using a smaller lens, you can probably get away with a standard ball mount. However if you're using a larger lens, ball mounts just don't work very well. One of your best options is a gimbal head. Once you get it properly set up and adjusted, the gimbal head lets you move your camera+lens in almost any direction with ease and if you take your hands off, it should stay pointed exactly where it's pointed. I resisted far too long switching to a gimbal head and I wish I could go back and yell at myself for doing so. To properly use a gimbal, your lens needs a lens foot and it should have a collar that can be loosened so that the lens rotates within the collar.

Another option that I've found works reasonably well and is much more compact than a gimbal is the FlexShooter. It's technically a ball head, but it works almost like a gimbal. It's not as good as a gimbal (in my opinion) but it is certainly more compact and much easier to travel with. It's expensive, but almost everything in photography is expensive.

If you're shooting from a monopod, I would recommend looking at Wimberly's MH-100 monopod head. It essentially gives you the type of functionality you would get from a full gimbal, but it relies on the fact that the monopod itself can rotate to give you left/right movement. It's small, relatively light and works well in my experience. This is my most common setup when photographing whales - a monopod with the MH-100 and a super-telephoto lens.


My Equipment​

I get this question often. Sometimes it's a genuine interest in what I'm using, but often it seems like the person is trying to justify why their photos don't look as good. When I tell them what I'm shooting with, they often respond with "well that explains it." And yes, some of my shots just aren't possible with some equipment. But there's also a very big element of the photographer's experience and skill which just gets glossed over completely. So I usually skip answering this question unless I feel like there's a more genuine interest with the question. But here I will answer the question, though I'm going to limit the answer to what I use for photographing whales.

I used to use a Nikon D850 as my camera body, and my primary whale lens was the 800mm F5.6 Nikon lens which is a beast of a lens. It's big, it's heavy and it's extremely expensive, but boy does it take beautiful images. When Nikon released the Z9, that was the body that finally got me to switch to MILC. While I still have my D850, I never shoot with the D850 any more. I only shoot the Z9. And I used to use the 800f5.6 with an adapter on my Z9, but with the release of the Nikon Z 800mm PF, that has become my primary whale lens. I especially like that it's light enough that I can hand-hold it reasonably well (though I still normally use a monopod).

I usually also have my Nikon 180-600mm zoom lens with me in case the whale gets too close for the 800mm. If I bring my camera backpack with me, I'll also have my "lens trinity" with me: 14-24mm f2.8, 24-70mm f2.8, 70-200mm f2.8. This trio of lenses is often referred to as the "holy trinity of lenses", as it's a great lineup for a wide variety of scenarios. However, after Nikon came out with their 24-120mm f4 lens, I now use just that instead of bringing the whole trio of lenses. The 24-120, 180-600 and 800 prime have become my trinity of lenses for whale photography (and a lot of my wildlife photography).

Other than the camera body and lenses, the other equipment I use:
  • Gitzo Monopod
  • Wimberley MH-100 MonoGimbal head
  • Gitzo tripod
  • Wimberley WH-200 Gimbal head
  • Shelta Seahawk hat
  • Country Innovation Raptor Waistcoat vest


Cleaning​

There's no getting around it - shooting around the ocean is difficult on camera gear. Keeping your gear clean goes a long way in avoiding premature failures, as well as getting better photos (by keeping your lens clean).

One of the harder tasks, especially if you're shooting from the beach and/or on a windy day, is keeping your lens clean. Using a lens hood helps, but if the wind is coming straight at you, it doesn't help much. I keep a lot of pre-moistened lens wipes (such as the Zeiss Lens Wipes) in my pockets. I also keep at least one, and usually a couple microfiber cloths, and I keep a small bottle of lens cleaning solution (such as the Zeiss lens cleaner). If I'm keeping on top of things, the lens wipes are often good enough. But if I get too much on the lens, I need to spray the lens with the lens cleaner. Yes, it's not generally recommended to spray directly on the lens, it's usually better to spray on a cloth and wipe, but if there's too much on the lens, you really need some extra liquid to help get the gunk off.

Once back at home, instead of using the lens wipes, I use Kimtech Kimwipes and a bottle of Zeiss Cleaner. I also use Pec Pad wipes to do the final "polish" - I find they work better than the Kimwipes for the final polish, while the Kimwipes work better for the cleaning. I've mostly given up on almost all types of cloths for cleaning my lenses. While it feels very wasteful to use disposable wipes, it just works so much better.

Note that it's good to do a good blast with an air blower (NOT compressed air), like a rocket blower before you start wiping your lens. This helps ensure there are no particles on your lens that might scratch it. If you have a number of lenses, and especially some big lenses, this can get tiring so I've gotten lazy and purchased a VSGO Electronic Air Blower.

Depending on how much ocean spray you've gotten on your lens, it might be difficult to really get it clean. If you're finding it difficult to get rid of all of the streaks and get your glass very clean, I'd recommend the advice given to me when I asked the LensRentals.com founder about this issue. His recommendation was to add a drop of mild dish detergent (such as Dawn) to a wet cloth and wipe the lens. Ocean spray often is a lot more oily than you might think and I've found this helps tremendously. I don't do it every time, I only do it when I'm having trouble getting the lens clean with the lens cleaner.

After a long session by the ocean it's also good to wipe everything down with a damp microfiber cloth. Salt spray gets onto and into everything. Another good addition is getting a protective cover for your flash hot shoe.

Avoid changing lenses as much as possible while near the ocean. Every time you open it up, you invite more salt air inside your camera. This eventually eats away components inside the camera and will leave you with a failing camera that requires an expensive repair.


Settings​

After equipment, settings is usually the most often-asked question. Again, this isn't going to be a comprehensive photographic guide/tutorial. I am assuming some basic knowledge and then providing recommendations specific to shooting whales.

RAW vs JPEG​

Most cameras give you the option to shoot in RAW mode. Even some of the higher end iPhone cameras now give you the option to shoot in RAW. Shooting in RAW means that, for the most part, it's just recording the actual data from the sensors - it's not trying to "interpret" the data. This gives you much more flexibility in post-processing (on your computer). When you shoot in RAW, you don't have to worry about what white-balance gets set, what "profile" is used and you typically get a wider dynamic range. So why would anyone want to shoot in a mode other than RAW? You shouldn't! Just kidding, there are valid reasons for shooting JPEG. One of the big reasons is that JPEG images will be smaller. This means they'll take up less space on your memory card and the camera will be able to write your image to card faster. It also is good if you don't want to do much, if any, editing on the computer and just want to use the image straight out of the camera. But in general, unless you have a specific need for shooting JPEG, you should consider always shooting RAW.

Aperture Priority, Shutter Priority, Manual?​

The vast majority of the time I'm shooting wildlife, I want to be able to control both the aperture and the shutter. I want to choose the aperture that will give me the depth of field I want, and I want to control the shutter speed according to my focal length and subject. So I typically shoot in some type of manual mode. If the lighting and situation aren't changing much, I generally shoot in full manual and choose the aperture, shutter and ISO to get the exposure I want. But if things are changing and/or I want to be ready for a variety of situations I often shoot in "manual with auto ISO". Most higher-end cameras have some version of this. Basically you choose the aperture and shutter, and the camera will choose the ISO to give what it thinks is the proper exposure. I also use this mode quite a bit if I'm trying to "ratchet down the ISO". This is a technique where I start with a conservatively-high shutter speed - something that I'm reasonably sure will avoid motion blur - and shoot a burst, then I'll drop the shutter speed a bit, shoot another burst, drop the shutter again, shoot another burst. This way I'm reasonably sure I at least get something even if it's more grainy than I'd like. And if I'm lucky, one of the slower shutter speed shots (with lower ISO) will come out OK and I get a cleaner shot as a result.

Shutter Speed​

Choosing the proper shutter speed depends on a variety of factors, but primarily the focal length of your lens and the speed/motion of the subject you are shooting. There is a standard rule of thumb for minimum shutter speed when hold-holding a camera, which is 1/length. So if you're shooting with a 600mm lens, your minimum shutter speed would be 1/600 second. Most modern lenses and cameras have image stabilization technology built-in, which allows you to shoot with slower shutter speeds. However that only affects the motion caused by physically hand-holding the camera/lens - it doesn't do anything for the speed/motion of the subject. You might end up with a generally clear photo with a blurry subject if the subject was moving during the photo.

For whale photos, I try to use the fastest shutter speed I can get away with given the amount of light available. The sweet spot for me is typically around 1/1250. However bear in mind that I'm usually shooting with an 800mm lens, sometimes with a 1.4X TC on. If I have enough light I'll often go more toward 1/1600 or even 1/2000 to really freeze the water droplets and/or fish flying out of the whale's mouth. I haven't really run into a scenario where I felt I needed more than 1/2000 for whales. If you are using a shorter lens, and especially if the whale is relatively far, you typically won't need quite as fast a shutter speed. But when in doubt, always err on the side of faster shutter speed. You can fix noisy/grainy photos on the computer, you can't fix motion blur. Well, technically you can fix a little bit of motion blur with software like Topaz, but you're far better off avoiding the blur.

On the slower side, if you don't have enough light, you can get away with fairly slow speeds, especially if you shoot in bursts. I've been able to get shots as slow as 1/100 if I'm being good about holding the camera steady, tracking/panning with the whale, and the whale isn't being too active. I can sometimes even get reasonable lunge shots as slow as 1/400 if I'm shooting a burst, but often only a few shots in the entire series may come out sharp enough.

If the whale is breaching or tail slapping, you'll want to be on the higher end and probably won't want to go too far below 1/1250. If the whale is fairly far away, you can get away with slower speeds because the amount of motion is relatively smaller than if the whale was closer. And as mentioned earlier, often once I've gotten some shots at a higher shutter speed, I'll drop the shutter speed a bit for the next shots, and keep going down. Just watch out with this technique because the whales like to play with photographers. They'll be somewhat sedate, so you ratchet down the shutter speed to get some cleaner shots and then they'll breach right when you've ratcheted all the way down to a slow shutter and you end up with a big blurry mess. They love to taunt me.

Aperture​

Typically this is an easy one for shooting the whales. Most of the time you want the widest aperture possible so that you can get the highest shutter and lowest ISO possible. When shooting from shore, the whales are often far enough away that your widest aperture will still provide enough depth of field to have the whole whale in focus. At 300 feet away, even a fast 600mm f4 lens has almost 20 feet depth of field. That will typically be enough for most whales. Of course if you want to do more of an environmental shot, such as getting a photo of the whale with land or the pier behind it, you'll need to use a smaller aperture.

Of course the real "problem" happens when you're on the pier and the whale decides to come right up to you! That necessitates a fast zoom-out and rapid spin of the aperture dial. However I'd never complain about this type of problem!

There are many online depth of field calculators, as well as apps you can download for your phone. I use PhotoPills, which used to be free for the basic version, but it looks like it's now $10.99. It has a lot of features and functionality in addition to depth of field, but I'm sure you can search and find a free app or online tool if you want to play around with apertures, distances and focal lengths to see what depth of field you might want/need.

Exposure Control​

If using full manual mode, exposure control doesn't really matter. But when shooting in aperture/shutter priority or manual-with-auto-ISO, exposure control tells the camera to over- or under-expose the scene a specified amount.

My general philosophy with most wildlife photos is to "protect the highlights". If you overexpose, there's no way to recover - the information/detail is lost. While it is possible to underexpose to the point where you lose all detail, that's much less common. You can often pull detail out of the deepest of shadows. It may be noisy/grainy but often that can be fixed with denoise software. If you overexpose, you're done - any pixel that is completely overexposed is just white and you've lost the detail. So when I'm shooting a dynamic scene, I almost always
intentionally underexpose by some amount. The most common setting I use is -0.7 stops. Depending on how bright it is, how much I want to protect the detail in the bright water splashes, and/or whether there's a white bird nearby, I might go down to -1.0 or even -1.3 stops. Of course this technique requires you to raise the overall exposure in post-processing (on your computer). If you don't plan on editing your photos at all,
you may not want to employ the strategy of underexposing, otherwise your photos will tend to look too dark and somewhat flat.

Some people may say, "but what about this Expose To The Right" philosophy I hear about? Briefly, that philosophy is that to get the best quality and widest dynamic range, you want to expose as bright as possible without completely blowing out the highlights. It's called Expose To The Right because it refers to the exposure histogram which shows bright pixels on the right side of the histogram. The theory encourages you to brighten the exposure until the histogram just touches the right side of the graph. There is merit in this philosophy and I often use it when I have more static scenes. But the risk of blowing out the highlights is too great in dynamic and fast-moving scenarios. Also note that this technique also requires you to edit the photos on your computer, to reduce the overall exposure to an appropriate level.

Autofocus​

Since every manufacturer has slightly different autofocus modes and features, it would be difficult to recommend a particular autofocus mode, but there are a few things that generally apply across cameras.

The first and most important thing to make sure is that you're in "continuous servo" mode. Each brand has a different name for this, but it's the mode where the camera continuously focuses while you're shooting and/or have the autofocus button pressed. On Nikon cameras, and several others, this is referred to as AFC mode. The other major mode is "single servo" which means once it has acquired focus, it stops trying to focus. When you have a moving subject, this often doesn't work very well unless you have a deep enough depth of field that it doesn't matter.

If you have a DSLR, you probably will have an option to pick the number and location of autofocus sensors the camera tries to use. In general you want to use the smallest number of autofocus points that still allow you to cover enough of the frame that the whale will be under those sensors. The fewer AF points you use, the faster and more accurately it will typically focus. It's been a while since I've shot with my DSLR, but my recollection is that I used to use Nikon's Dynamic AF9 mode which used 9 sensors.

If you have a MILC, they usually also have an option to specify the area under which they try to focus, but they're usually a lot more flexible. MILCs generally are able to focus on any part of the frame, whereas DSLRs are more limited and are more focused on the center of the frame. MILCs also tend to have subject detection options. Here they will attempt to identify the actual subject and focus on that. They will also try to find the portion of the subject that you are most likely to want in focus. For animals that's usually the eye. They will often start by focusing on the subject in general, then trying to identify the head and focusing on that, and then try to find the eye and focus on that. Once subject detection is locked on, they can follow the subject wherever it goes in the frame, as long as it's within the boundaries you specified for autofocus. This is a huge benefit when shooting wildlife. Getting (and keeping) good focus is often significantly easier with MILCs as compared to DSLRs. Again, that's not to say you can't get similar results with DSLRs, it's just easier to do with MILCs.

I use and generally recommend what they call "back button focus". What this means is that you use a button to specifically engage the autofocus, and it will only focus while you're pressing that button regardless of whether you're pressing the shutter button. Most cameras default to engaging autofocus when you push (or half push) the shutter button. I like to separate the actions of focus and shutter.

As for how I set up my Z9's focus ... I actually have different focus modes programmed to 3 different buttons. I have one button that is my autofocus button, which engages autofocus using whatever mode I currently have set (which I usually have set to AutoAF). I have one button set to be a custom WideAF mode that is slightly larger than the WideMedAF mode. I have one button set to a custom WideAF mode that is basically just a 1x1 box. This allows me to get more or less specific with the subject I'm trying to focus on.

I'll usually start with either the 1x1 box if I think I can get it right on the whale quickly, or I'll start with the larger WideAF mode. Once subject detection has locked on to the whale, I switch to the basic autofocus button (which usually is set for AutoAF) so that it can follow the whale anywhere in the frame. I know, this is a little confusing and I may try to clear things up later. But since this is pretty specific to the Nikon Z9 I'm not going to dive too deep on this right now.

I strongly recommend reading up on all of the details of the autofocus modes your camera provides and become proficient in using the modes effectively and knowing where the weaknesses are. You can save a photo from a lot of mistakes, but you can't really fix an out of focus shot.


Shooting Strategies​

This section goes over some more general strategies for trying to shoot the whales and is less specific to camera equipment.


Get the shot!​

I regularly use some variation of the phrase: "The shot you got will always be better than the shot you didn't get." While that may seem trite and obvious, there's some subtlety to it. The point is that your first goal should be to get something even if it's not perfect. Just get a shot. There are so many things that can be fixed in post-processing if you screwed something up. But the thing you can't fix is failing to get anything.

I will often start shooting even before I have the camera necessarily on the subject and/or focused. And I try to leave the camera settings in a state that if I at least hit the shutter button, I'm likely to get something I can work with. For me, shooting whales, that's often Manual with Auto-ISO, F5.6 (on my 800mm prime), 1/1250, exposure compensation -0.7, prefocused to about where the whales are.

There are other, similar subtleties to the statement, such as the idea of starting off with a shutter speed high enough to be reasonably sure you'll get something without motion blur, and then ratcheting down the shutter speed after you've gotten a few shots. Again, the first goal is to get the shot, then you can work on getting a better shot.

This also applies to camera choice, lens choice, etc. If I don't have my big camera with me and/or ready, but I have my cell phone, I'll first try to get a shot with my cell phone and then if there's time I'll go get my big camera. Or if I have the "wrong lens" on for the shot, I'll first try to get a shot with the wrong lens and then swap lenses if I have time. Get something, then try to get something better.


Time of Day​

One of the most common questions is "when should I come if I want to see the whales?" For the (non-)answer to this question, you can read my guide on whale watching in Pacifica. But the short answer is that there's no particular time when the whales always show up. It depends on a variety of factors, but primarily "where's the food?"

So we're largely dependent on the whales, their moods and where the food is for getting photos of them. But when/if I have a choice, I often like shooting early in the morning. When shooting from shore, the morning light illuminates them beautifully and isn't as harsh as mid-day sun. You're also less likely to have heat distortion which is discussed in more length later.

Shooting in the evening is a bit more challenging because the whales are typically backlit. And if they're feeling particularly devious, they will line up directly with the sun, mostly blinding the photographer and their camera. But you can still get good shots in the evening. You can adjust your exposure compensation or choose appropriate settings in full manual mode so that you expose the whale properly. You can also go the other direction and intentionally silhouette the whale, which can be a nice shot too. I've gotten a few where I silhouetted the whale and the shadow of the whale's tail was visible in the water spray from its tail slapping, which makes for a fun shot.

Mid-day sun is the harshest light to be shooting, but we often don't have the choice. It does have the advantage of having a lot more light, allowing faster shutter speeds and lower ISOs. But especially during mid-day shooting, be careful about blowing out the highlights, as discussed earlier in the exposure compensation section. The whales often have white on them, plus the frothing water is quite bright, so you want to try and protect the highlights. You can even things out in post-processing, dropping the highlights and raising the shadows. If I'm shooting mid-day, I often hope for it to be a cloudy day. You get much more even lighting when it's cloudy and you often have more light than you think you do. Many people see a sunny day and say "great day to take photos!" When I see a cloudy day, that's when I say "great day to take photos!"


Location​

You often don't have a lot of choice here with the whales. You have to go where they are, and you have limited choices from where to view them. But there are a few things to keep in mind.

Heat Distortion​

This was mentioned earlier. Any time you have a mixing of warm and cool air, you can get heat distortion. The only thing you can do about it is to move to a spot that minimizes it. If you're shooting on the beach or near the beach, the sun will often be warming up the sand, causing lots of hot air to rise, which then mixes with the cool air from the water. Your best bet is to get as close to the water's edge as possible. Of course now you're going to start running into issues of keeping your lens free of salt spray, so it's a balancing act. And similarly, if you're standing in a parking lot over hot asphalt, you're going to have a problem. If you're standing at the edge of a cliff by a somewhat wide beach (think Esplanade area) you'll have the warm air rising from the beach and you're still going to have a problem. At Mussel rock, getting out as far on the point as you can so you have less land between you and the ocean helps.

Generally anything you can do to avoid being around warm land helps. This is also where shooting in the morning helps because the land hasn't yet started to warm up. Evenings are particularly difficult because the land has been baking all day (unless we have one of our foggy and/or cloudy days, which really help mitigate the heat distortion). This is also a reason shooting from the pier is one of my favorites because it's less of an issue. You can still have trouble, even on the pier, if we're getting winds from the East because it's bringing that warm air from the land out over the pier where it mixes with the cool ocean air. But in general, the pier is a good place to try and avoid heat distortion.

It's annoying and can be difficult, and often you don't even realize it's happening in the moment unless you're looking very carefully at the photos on the back of your camera. But as long as you know what to look for, you can look for ways to mitigate the problem.

Perspective​

Often, especially shooting from shore, you don't have a lot of choices for perspective. As a general rule, trying to "get lower" provides for more dramatic and interesting shots. But the locations we have at our disposal and how much the whales move around often make this difficult. And the lower you get, the harder it is to get decent views of the whales when the waves are larger. But if you get the chance, try to find lower spots from which to get shots. Just don't forget to follow the basic rule of "Get the shot!". Before you try to get a better perspective, first get something. Then try to get something more interesting.

There are a few benefits to shooting from a low perspective, especially when photographing wildlife. It puts you closer to being on the same level as the wildlife which helps the viewer feel more a part of the scene/action. It also tends to help give you more subject isolation. If you’re shooting down on something, almost everything in frame is going to be in focus, because the ground/ocean/etc is at about the same distance as the subject. However when you’re down low, what’s in front and behind can be very, very far away, putting it out of focus and giving you better isolation for the subject. Low perspective also tends to increase the "drama" of the photo.

If you're shooting with a long lens, getting low is often one of the only ways you can get "environmental" shots - shots with the whales, as well as something else (the beach, the pier, rocks, the horizon, the sun, a boat, etc.). While closeup, detailed shots are great, they can get a little monotonous. Having other elements in the photo can bring additional perspective and interest in the photo.

The downside to a low perspective is it's more difficult to get a decent shot. There are a few reasons for this. The first reason is that it's more difficult to achieve proper focus. When you’re shooting down on a subject, the ground, ocean, etc that’s in frame is at roughly the same distance as the subject. So even if your auto focus misses the subject, it’ll hit the surface around it and you’ll often be "close enough" on the focus. When you’re shooting low perspective if you aim a little high or low, you might be aiming way behind or way in front of the subject. It’s much more important to get the AF directly on the subject when shooting low - if you miss by a little, you miss by a lot.

The second reason is that it's harder to track the whales and get your lens on them. It's often difficult to see some of the cues, such as the footprints and the jumping bait fish. And, especially if there are some waves, it can be a lot more difficult to see when they first break the surface of the water.

And finally, you tend to have a narrower field of view and/or range in which you can get shots. This can lead to a lot more walking to get into place. Trying to chase whales is exhausting. Sometimes you get lucky and the whales are either staying in the same area, or they are "swimming laps". This happens a lot between the pier and Mori Point. More than any other place in Pacifica, I've seen them swimming back and forth between the pier and Mori. If they're doing that, just find a good place to set up and wait for them to come to you. If you watch them long enough, you might find that there are certain spots where they are stopping to lunge. That would be a good place to set up.

The long and short of it is that low perspective shots are harder and there's a lower probability of getting many, if any, shots. If you do get the shot, it will likely be a "better" shot. If you're just starting out, especially with a long lens, you may want to start with higher perspective shots, build up your skills and confidence, and then try moving low. If you find yourself getting so frustrated it's no longer enjoyable, just head back high for a while.

To Follow or Not?​

That's the tough question every single time. When the whales move to a new location, do you try to follow them? I don't have a great answer, and I get it wrong about as many times as I get it right. If you move, and they don't come back to where you were, then you made the right choice. If you move, and then they go right back to where you were, you made the wrong choice. I swear they toy with me a lot. If you watch them long enough you can sometimes get a sense for whether they're hanging around in an area, or if they're "swimming laps" between locations, or if they're just headed on out. Take a guess, flip a coin ... I'd say more often than not I've regretted moving, for whatever that's worth.


Getting the Whale in Frame​

This is one of the hardest parts about shooting whales. Since they spend most of their time underwater, can move deceptively fast, and can change directions underwater at any time, they can be really difficult to get the camera on when they do surface.

Sometimes you're lucky and it's easy. If they start a tail-slapping session, they usually stay in that spot for a while slapping, giving you many opportunities to make sure you have the camera pointed correctly, focus correct, and time to experiment with different shutter/exposure settings. You can even try switching to video once you've gotten some still shots. You can also get lucky if they're spending a lot of time feeding in one spot. You may not know exactly where the next lunge will be, but you'll know the general area and can be somewhat ready.


Tracking the Whales​

The hard part comes when they're moving around a lot. One trick I've been able to at least partially be successful with is to keep a running timer in my head and also do my best to estimate how fast they're moving. As soon as I see them surface, I start counting in my head. There's often a bit of a pattern with how frequently they come up. By counting off the interval, I can sometimes have an approximate idea of when they'll surface next. And if I'm estimating their speed, I can have a general idea where they'll likely turn up (unless of course they take a u-turn or hard-turn underwater, which they love to do ...). If you do it enough, timing in your head becomes automatic and you start to get a feeling for when they'll be up again. It's not perfect, but I think it helps.

Another trick that can work pretty well, especially if they are somewhat close and/or you're on a boat, is to watch for their "footprints". Whales move a lot of water as they move those big tails of theirs. When this water reaches the surface, it creates a large flat circle. This circle is called a whale footprint. You can use these to help track the movements of the whales while they are underwater. Just keep in mind that it takes a little time for that water to reach the surface, depending on how deep the whale is. So the whale will generally be a little distance ahead of the footprints.

If the whales are close by, you can sometimes get an idea of where a whale is and when it is about to surface by watching and listening for the bait fish to come jumping out of the water. It sounds almost like water washing over sand or rocks.

This is what you may see and/or hear first:

_DSC5511-Enhanced-NR.jpg


And then, if you're lucky, you may see something like this:

_DSC7842-Enhanced-NR-Edit-2.jpg


In general, try to keep alert for sounds. The whales can often be tricky. I'll be focusing in on a particular whale, tracking its movements and then suddenly I'll hear a spout occur behind me. I think they do this on purpose to play games with me. "Hey George, you try to get his attention while I circle behind him and provide a beautiful photo opportunity that he'll never have time to swing around photograph." Of course listening can be difficult if, like me, you easily get pulled into conversations with people nearby. But that's part of the fun and challenge of photographing these tricksters.

One of the most common pieces of advice people provide to me is "just watch the birds, you'll be able to easily got shots of whales every time." While it sometimes is helpful, and I'm willing to use any trick possible, I find it rare that watching the birds helps very much. There are two parts to the advice given: 1) Just look where the birds are gathering and diving for fish, the whales will be there too. 2) Watch for when all of the birds take off at once, that usually means a whale is coming up to lunge feed.

Unfortunately there is often a low correlation with these events. While there may be times when whales happen to be in the same area as large groups of birds, far more often there are birds and no whales. It's also common for there to be whales and no birds. And it's common for birds to all take flight at the same time even without whales being nearby or about to lunge feed. By all means, use the birds to your advantage if they happen to be helping you find and track the whales. But please try to avoid handing out this advice as a sure-fire way of getting spectacular whale photos.

And for the fun of it, here are a few photos birds around the whales, in part to head off the "But here's a photo with birds and a whale proving that the advice is sound!" responses.

_DSC5441-Enhanced-Edit.jpg


_DSC0072-Enhanced-NR.jpg


_DSC7819-Enhanced-NR.jpg

As helpful as it is knowing ways to track where the whales are, it is also important to understand when they've likely left or will be down for a while. One tell-tale sign is a prominent fluke. When whales are about to dive deep and/or go down for a while, they lift their tail into the air to help thrust its body into a deep descent. That doesn't necessarily mean you need to leave (keep in mind the "patience" mentioned later in this guide), but if you're near the end of your time photographing the whales and are looking for a sign that it's time to go, this is often a nice fairwell. Just keep in mind that this type of fluking behavior is distinctly different than when they are tail slapping, or throwing their tails up in the air and/or Peduncle-slapping (see the Whale Glossary). In this maneuver, the whale is raising its tail and it will slide down into the water.


_DSC2675-Enhanced-NR.jpg



Pointing the Camera​

Even if you're doing a reasonably good job guessing where they're going to be, or if they're mostly in the same area, you still need to get the camera pointed directly at them. As discussed earlier, this isn't the easiest task, especially with super telephoto lenses. When I'm hand-holding my camera, the method I use is to first lock my eyes and head on the whale, then bring the camera up without moving my head at all. Generally I'll be pretty close when I do this, but it does take practice. You can practice this any time, anywhere. Pick a target and then try to bring your camera up and get it pointed at it immediately. If you do this enough times, you'll build a muscle memory and you'll tend to get pretty close.

If I'm using a monopod, I usually have one hand on top of the lens near the end and the other hand gripping the camera with my finger over the shutter button. I stand behind and use the lens itself almost like a gun sight and I line things up with the target just above the end of the lens, then I drop my head down to the viewfinder. This is another one that takes practice. But if you do it enough times, you build a muscle memory and you find that you can get pretty close.


Be There​

You must play to win. The only way to get good whale shots is to get out there. Often. The more you're out there, the more you learn about the whale behaviors, the more chances you'll have of taking shots, and the better you will get. It may sound obvious, but the best thing you can do to get better photos is to get out there, keep looking and keep trying. Getting good photos also requires a lot of patience. You may need to be out there for long stretches of time just waiting for the whales to show up, or for them to return. The nice part is that there is often beautiful scenery, birds, sea lions and other interesting things to watch and photograph while you wait. Just try not to get too distracted. I sometimes find myself getting very focused on getting photographs of some of the birds, only to hear the shouts of "whale!" by those nearby, and realize I just missed a great opportunity.

And of course, follow the Pacifica Whale Sightings Forum and/or Pacifica Whalespotting Facebook group to see where others are seeing the whales and PLEASE update the group on any sightings you have!

Questions?​

Still have questions? Did I miss something you'd like addressed? Did I get something wrong? Please post a message in this forum.

_DSC2431-Enhanced-NR-Edit-2.jpg


 
Last edited:
Back
Top